Trading Places

Note : This story is completely fictional!

I’ve lived next door to my best friend Eve for my entire life. She and I might as well be twin sisters, and that’s basically how our families treat us. We’re both blond and slim, both on the cheerleading squad at the local high school, and we both have the coolest older brothers ever. Like Eve and I, my brother Mark, and Eve’s brother Ryan, are best friends as well. The guys are only two years older than us, and we all hang out with the same crowd, so we’re all pretty close. As I’m sure you’ve guessed by now, we got much closer.

Eve had just turned 17, three weeks after I did. Since we were both horny little teenagers, I wanted to do something cool and sexy for her birthday. My plan was to put on some make up, and sneak into the Adult bookstore to do a little shopping. I couldn’t believe it when I got away with it. Once inside, I started to look around for something really kinky. After poking around a bit, and soaking my panties looking at all the cool porn, I found this realistic looking rubber cock that vibrated. Blushing, I laid the box on the counter, fumbling with my money while the sales guy stared at my short little skirt. I paid the guy, and ran out of there fast!

That night, Eve and I were hanging out in her parent’s basement rec room, listening to Blink-182. I couldn’t wait to see the look on her face when she opened my gift, so I pulled the brightly wrapped package out from my backpack, and put it in her small, slender hands. Paper and ribbons floated to the floor as she ripped open the present. I broke out in a fit of giggles as her eyes went round, and she let out a long squeal.

“Oh my god, eeeeeeeewwwww Shannon!” Then she eyed the faux-phallic with cartoon lust. I laughed (so typical horn-dog Eve), and I have to admit now, found the whole scene really sexy.

“Pull it out of the box!” I pleaded, “I want to check this thing out!”

Teasing me, Eve pulled it away, “Me first!”

Eve pulled the massive cock out from its package. It was amazing how real the dildo looked. Although I was still a virgin at the time, my brother Mark and I had played around our whole life, mostly innocent, having only gone so far as the “show-me” stage (with a little petting, and a lot of necking thrown in). So, I was not unfamiliar with the male penis.

Eve started stroking the shaft, and we giggled when she started to lay kisses on the rubber crown. I was a little shocked at Eve’s behavior, but even more shocked at my own response. Watching by best friend as she began to deep-throat her new toy turned me on totally. My heart was pounding, my breathing quick and shallow, and my pussy was creaming into my cotton panties as my lust grew.

Eve pulled the dildo out of her mouth, and dangled it before my face. I let my tongue slide out over my lips, and ran it up and down the shaft. My itching slit made me bold, and I felt tiny electric-like shocks shoot through me as I played my tongue around Eve’s fingers, which were wrapped around the base of the dildo. My best friend stared at me, her face flushed, her blue eyes glistening with obvious lust. I’d always wanted to try girl/girl sex with Eve, and now that the door of opportunity was open, I had to act.

I reached over and took the dildo out of her hand. I smiled slyly, and whispered, “I want to fuck your little pussy with your new toy.”

She bit her lower lip, not saying a word. But she spread her slender tan legs wide, revealing a slice of silky panties, a tiny wet spot in the center. I had her permission. She leaned back on the sofa, and I knelt between her legs. I pushed her dress up. The scent coming off her was strong, sexually musky, the smell of a 17 year old girl in heat. My thumbs hooked into the elastic waistband of her undies, and in one smooth motion, I pulled them clean over her dainty ankles.

Her little blondish muff shimmered with erotic luster, the pink lips well oiled and ready for sex. I teased her tender vulva a bit with the cock head, and she was already moaning with delight. I switched on the vibrator. Eve let out a whimper. Placing the humming phallus to her moist flower, I began to push it gently inside her l. Inch by inch I guided the dildo into her pussy hole. Eve was babbling, and had raised her tank top up over her growing boobs so she could pull at her erect pink nipples. As the rubber dick slid in and our of her slurpy hole, I saw that her adorable clitty needed some attention. I bent down and began to flick my tongue over her nubby. She sighed loudly, and twitched on the sofa in bliss.

Eve and I were too lost in our lesbian play to hear the door open at the top of the stairs. We never heard our brothers, Mark and Ryan, come down the stairs. We did hear their loud gasps of shock as they saw their little sisters sprawled half naked on the sofa. Too late to make a bit of difference, Eve and I scrambled to cover up.

“Oh my god, Mark!” laughed Ryan, “Our sisters are fucking lesbos!”

Mark grinned at me and winked, “I always suspected as much.”

Eve’s face was red with embarrassment and anger. “Shut up Ryan! We’re not lesbos!”

“Yeah,” I jumped in, “we like guys too!”

Ryan and Mark continued to tease us, insisting we were hard-core dykes, drawing visual pictures of us with hairy legs and butch-like hair cuts. Finally, Eve could take no more.

She walked over to my brother, and then got down on her knees. “I think this should prove, without a doubt, that you guys are full of shit.”

Mark and Ryan exchanged surprised glances as Eve lowered my brother’s zipper. I was horny as hell, all worked up with my little session with Eve, so more for a desire to have Ryan’s dick in my mouth than any urge to prove my sexual preferences, I knelt before Eve’s brother. We unbuckled, unflyed, and unzipped, leaving the boys with their pants around their ankles. Soon, we were hungrily sucking their meaty cocks. We watched each other intently, and the sight of my brother’s cock slipping in and out of Eve’s open throat turned me on incredibly. Then I looked up at Mark, and that’s when I noticed my brother staring at me with lust. I wasn’t surprised when I looked over at Ryan, and noticed his gaze riveted on the sight of his little sister drooling all over Mark’s magnificent penis.

Eve sucking lavishly on my brother was now giving me ideas. Of course, I had always wanted to go all the way with Mark. All that incestuous flirting and petting with him behind my parent’s back was hot, and I wanted to fuck my brother in the worst way. I was sure he felt the same way, but the taboo aspect of the whole thing made us a bit too chicken to go through with it. As I watched Eve slurping sweetly on Mark’s hot, wet meat, I desperately wanted a taste.

Then, the most incredible thing happened.

Eve pulled Mark’s cock from her lips and looked at me. She asked, “How do you like my big brother’s dick, Shannon?”

“Mmmmm,” I answered, “I love it.”

She looked at me, and I knew she wanted to say something else. She couldn’t spit out the words, but the way she was gazing at her brother’s cock, I guessed she was horny for her own brother – just like me.

I decided to chance it. “How would you like to do something really naughty, Eve?”

“What?”

“Let’s trade. Let’s suck off our own brothers!”

I glanced up for a reaction. The look on Ryan and Mark’s face made it abundantly clear that they loved the idea. Eve paused only a second, and smiled wide when I wagged her brother’s cock in her direction. Eve and I traded places.