First time and what great fun

Lucy laid down on the bed still moaning from her orgasm while I got ready for what I was waiting my whole life it seems. I got the lubricant she took out earlier and applied it to my hard cock. Then I raised her legs in the air and placed them on my shoulders while applying the lubricant to her pink anus. She moaned lightly as I inserted my forefinger and then the middle finger getting as much lubricant inside as I could. With her legs still on my shoulders and me kneeling on the floor I put the tip of my penis against her asshole. She shuddered in anticipation and I thought of using a condom, but since we both trusted each other I decided against it just so I could feel the full ecstasy not hindered by the rubber. I slowly pushed in and again Lucy moaned. Once the head was in, I stopped for a bit so she could get used to it and as soon as she relaxed I began to go further in. The feeling was awesome. It was very tight and hot, and every time I moved back out it tightened around my cock as if she didn’t want my cock to leave creating even more pleasure for me. 

She said that it hurt but since I took it real slow she didn’t tell me to stop. Soon I could feel that she got used to it and the pain subsided so I picked up the pace. Before long I was literally fucking her. She moaned a lot and I noticed that every time she screamed her voice was a little bit different than before. A few minutes later I stopped and pulled out of her, then I lay beside her and we embraced in a kiss. She then got on her knees and hands and I knelt behind her. After putting on a bit more lubricant I entered her from behind in the doggy position. It was more comfortable for her this way and so I fucked her again as hard as I could. I knew I wouldn’t last long like this and Lucy was screaming again, her voice was sounding even more like a guys but it didn’t bother me since I was in pure ecstasy. Just a few short minutes into it I looked into the mirror and the side view of us drove me over the top and I started to cum deep into her ass. With every squirt I plunged my self as hard and fast as I could making a loud slapping noise as my crotch collided with her round ass and my testicles slapped against hers. 

I think that it was the sight of her half hard cock flopping back and forth with every thrust that drove me into the most powerful orgasm yet. I kept thrusting in and out of her until I was too tired to continue. Then I finally pulled out and dropped on the bed while Lucy just melted down beside me still moaning and breathing really hard. When she caught her breath back, Lucy went down on me again and licked up some of the sperm that was still leaking out of me. Then she slowly left the room for a few minutes. 

When she returned, I noticed right of the bat that she was very different. The makeup and bra were gone, her hair was wet and tied back, and the way she stood in the doorway stroking her hard cock told me that Lucy was gone and Lucas has come to play. At first he had surprised me, but then I surprised my self. Even though we agreed that I was going to be with Lucy tonight, I smiled and waved Lucas over to me. He was glad to see me approve and came over grinning at me. “I’m gonna love you like you’ve never been loved before.” he said in his regular but still rather high pitched voice and he sat down in my lap pressing his hard cock to my chest. We kissed for a few minutes until he took charge and laid me down on my stomach. I knew what was coming and I started to tingle all over with anticipation. I almost jumped up when he suddenly stuck a finger covered in cool lubricant into my asshole. After fingering me at first with one, then two fingers, he told me to relax and stick my butt up in the air. 

As I did this he placed a pillow under my stomach and I laid down in a position that perfectly exposed my virgin ass to him. Seconds later the tip of his well-lubricated dick was spreading my anus. I learned very quickly that less I resisted the less painful it was so I just closed my eyes and let it all happen leaving my whole body as loose and relaxed as I could manage. He took it slow and went a little further in with every push. I concentrated on the reflection in the mirror to take my mind off the pain, what I saw I couldn’t believe. Lucas knew from the lack of my moaning that I was in a lot of pain so he pulled out and told me to lie down on my back with my ass on the pillow. I obeyed him with out question and he spread my legs apart and lifted them in the air. Now I felt even more vulnerable but as soon as he entered me again I realized that the pain was almost all gone. 

Shortly after he was leaning over me looking me in the eyes and fucking me so hard that I was screaming. But it wasn’t because of pain. Every time his cock pushed against my prostate I felt a rush of blood and excitement pulse through my dick and balls, the sensations were so incredible that I started to get a hard on again. I have heard that the stimulation of the prostate is the best part of anal sex but I never thought it would feel this good. Looking in the mirror I saw just how hard I was being fucked and I noticed that my cock was leaking a lot of precum, which has never happened like that before, I was gonna cum again soon. At the same time Lucas slowed his pace but his thrusts got more powerful and he was drilling deeper inside me then ever, the look on his face told me that he was cumming. He came for a long time and didn’t stop fucking me for more than five minutes. Between his moans and mine, I barely noticed that I squirted hot semen all over my belly button. When Lucas finished, he pulled out of me and let my legs down on the bed. It was then that the pain of being fucked so hard came back, but even worse was the feeling of emptiness left by his cock. I almost asked him to go back in but I knew that we were both way to tired to go on. 

Needless to say I got fucked and I loved it. Lucas had a big smile on his cute face as he slapped his sperm drenched cock onto my face. I took it into my mouth and sucked of all his cum enjoying every bit of it. During this I stuck a finger into my asshole and found that it was not only stretched and very soft but it was leaking Lucas’ cum all over the bed. Lucas pulled his now shrunken cock out of my mouth and turned around, then to my surprise he dipped his dick and balls into the sperm that has pooled on my belly button and moved his genitals right over my face so that my own cum was now dripping down on me. I licked and sucked up all of my own cum and was begging for more while he cleaned up the sperm on my stomach. Shortly he began to suck my balls and I got brave enough to try something I wanted to do for a long time. Since we were locked in a perfect 69 he moved down to give me access to his asshole and I made love to it. First I licked and kissed it then started to stick my tongue inside as deep as I could. 

When he saw that he wasn’t going to get any more reaction from my cock, he sat up to give me even better access and really started to enjoy the attention I was giving his anus. After fingering his ass for a bit I was rewarded with a bit of my own sperm dripping out of it and I licked it up without a moments hesitation. At that precise moment it really dawned on me what has just happened. Until now it was more like some unreal fantasy, more like a dream than anything. But now I see that this morning I was a lonely, straight, virgin guy looking for some excitement, some change in my life; and now I’m lying here licking my own sperm out of some guys asshole and my own ass is burning from being fucked like a cheap hooker. I stopped everything and just lay there absorbing this moment with a smile on my face. Lucas climbed off of me lay beside me embracing me in a soft hug. My ass was now in a pool of cum and lubricant, I could feel the sticky cum on my stomach and my face too. We were both lying on our sides looking into the mirror; tired, hot and sweaty, the smell of dirty sex was filling our nostrils. 

We hadn’t said a word for a while now and not wanting to break the peaceful silence I kissed the back of Lucas’ neck to tell him that I definitely approve of all that has happened today. His answer was the very same cute smile he gave me earlier in the park. That’s when I started to see him differently again. I no longer made any distinction between Lucas and Lucy; they were one and the same person. The genitals and the lack of breasts showed a boy, but the feminine body, gorgeous face and female mannerisms created a woman that none could second-guess. We lay like this for a while, enjoying each other’s company and not saying anything. We both felt complete. 

Later we took a bath together where we washed each other’s bodies and kept on kissing and hugging the entire time, we just couldn’t get enough of each other. When the time came to say goodbye, we were both very reluctant to separate; but we did finally exchange numbers and I left for a pleasant walk home. Well almost completely pleasant since my ass was still burning from the abuse it received earlier. The whole time I walked I thought of nothing more than the soft skin of the beautiful boy I made love to that day and I couldn’t wait to see him again.