Donna's Choice

 I was eighteen and had just graduated high school. Donna was eighteen also and had just finished her first year of college. We'd been dating for a while but hadn't had sex yet. She wanted to wait until she was married. Donna was not very experienced when we first were together. I had to teach her how to jerk my cock so that I would cum, as she did not know how. Her old boyfriend Will had only sucked her tits and fingered her pussy. I knew him pretty well and he told me he was going to dump her because she was "locked together at the knees". I guess he just didn't have the right key.

I liked Donna and we we fun together sexually. I'd finger her, she'd give me handjobs, and we'd give each other head. Once she even gave me a blowjob while I was driving her back to her parent's house. We'd mess around in my bedroom. I'd position myself above her missionary style and she would jerk me off until I came on her milky, toned stomach. We would then embrace and both wind up with tummies coated in sperm. I always fantasized about coming all over her pretty blonde snatch, but she wasn't on the pill so we didn't take chances.

One day we were in my bedroom fooling around on my bed. We had removed our clothes and were up to our usual activities. I was kissing Donna and embracing her lovely young body. She was about 5'5", 115 llbs, with firm 36B tits. I spread her legs and licked her virgin pussy, paying special attention to her clit. I loved everything about her cunt, the taste, the sweet smell, and how her light blonde pubic hair framed those perfect pink pussy lips. She in turn sucked my cock, taking almost all of it lovingly into her pretty little mouth. The warmth of her mouth felt incredible despite the occasional tooth scrape.

Donna took her mouth off of my cock and climbed on top of me. We kissed and I sucked on her half dollar sized nipples. She positioned her gash over my cock and before I knew it I was halfway inside her. I was taken quite by surprise. She told me she didn't want to wait anymore, she wanted to make love. I wanted to fuck her so bad. I wanted to see her pale ass bouncing up and down on my hard shaft, her child bearing hips grinding against my loins. More than anything I wanted to shoot a huge, hot load of my young seed into her fertile virgin cunt. It took all of the self control that I could muster to overcome the animal instincts telling me to impregnate this girl. We both agreed to stop until we got some protection. The last thing we needed was for her to get knocked up. Unfortunately, we had no condoms since I thought Donna wasn't going to be ready for sex for a while longer.

Later she went to Planned Parenthood to get on the pill. They gave her some condoms to use in the meantime. We went to a nearby town and got a cheap motel room. We'd gotten rooms before, but this was special. We couldn't wait to get in there. Our clothes were shed in no time. I fingered her gently as she stroked my cock with her slender fingers. We got on the bed and sixty-nined for a bit. I would usually cum when we did this, but not this time. As I licked and kissed her love hole I knew that my dick would soon be inside it, that her precious virginity would be gone forever, and that I would be the one who took it. We were both ready. I tore open the condom and unrolled the cold red latex over my erect shaft.

Donna was on her back on the bed. She spread her beautiful legs slightly, inviting me to mount her for the first time, the first time any man had received this invitation from her. I got on top of her and guided my cock into her wet little pussy. She let out a little moan, more of pleasure that of pain, as I filled her fresh young cunt. I gently fucked her, wishing that there was no rubber in between us. She rubbed my back and ass as we made love. We French kissed passionately almost the entire time. I could feel the warmth of her love canal through the condom. Our fuck session lasted for about half an hour. I don't know how I went that long as I was so excited about being inside Donna for the first time. Finally her tight pussy worked its magic as I filled the inside of the rubber with my thick, white load. We kissed as I grabbed the base of my cock and removed it from Donna's cunt before I started to go soft.

Soon we were able to fuck without condoms as the pill took effect. I filled Donna with cum many times after that, but I always wished that I would have come inside her the day she slid her unprotected pussy partially onto my stiff shaft. I regret not filling her young womb with my seed. Who knows, maybe her belly would have started to swell as my child grew inside of her, but probably not.