Caught with more than pants down

A few weeks ago I was caught red handed by my girlfriend's younger sister when I was banging another girl from our town.

It was a Friday night and my girlfriend was otherwise occupied babysitting for a friend of hers. Sometimes I went along but since her friend had her second kid, romantic nights were now accompanied by constant screaming from the new arrival so I decided to skip my budding babysitting career. It turned out quite well for me because I started seeing this other girl, Paula, who was an absolute knockout.

I first met her through another friend and was struck straight away by how sexy she was. She had the best ass I had seen in quite some time and she had this smoky sultry thing going on the whole time. One thing led to another and soon we were going at it like rabbits whenever the occasion allowed. She was fantastic in bed, much naughtier than my girlfriend. Both gave great head but Paula had no problem taking a mouthful of cum which was something my girlfriend refused to do. We often kissed after I blew a load in her mouth as I liked a little salt myself from time to time. Paula also had some very dirty fantasies including group sex and incest which I liked to share.

It wasn't all great though as my girlfriend had no problem licking my asshole which Paula rarely did. I would be in absolute heaven when I was whacking away on my average size hard-on with my girlfriend tonguing for all she was worth. Many times I had fantasized about Paula sucking my cock while my girlfriend was licking my balls and my ass and it never failed to result in a big load being blasted into the air - pity it wasn't Paula's mouth.

Anyway on this Friday night, I had rented the best porno I could find in preparation for a steamy night ahead with Paula. The video stores in my town did not have a great selection and I had seen most of them before however there was one group sex one I liked involving twin sisters which always got me going.

Paula arrived at 10 p.m. and we went straight up to my room and I turned on the film. We just lay there naked as the story got going but it wasn't long until we were engaged in all sorts of action including 69 and oral. Paula went down on me at one stage and I knew it would not be long before I would be blowing my first load of the night. As with all first loads it was pretty big specially since I hadn't had any sex with my g/f for a week who was having her period. She drank what cum she could could but some escaped onto the sides of the mouth and down onto her 32C breasts. She then came face to face with me and we kissed for a while so I tasted some of my own seed. I then licked her breasts clean and bit lightly on her nipples which she always enjoyed. As I made my down her oh-so-flat belly, I kissed around her belly ring and down towards her shaved pussy. I licked and fingered her to a string of orgasms and I had a great time lapping up her juices.

While all this was going on, the best group scene in the film was taking place with the twin sisters on their hands and knees facing each other and kissing while they were being banged by six guys taking turns to fuck them. When one guy was finished another would take his place and pretty soon their pussies were flooded with cum. This really got Paula going and she asked if her pussy could be flooded similarly. As I teased her pussy with my rock hard cock I fantasized with her about who she'd like to have in the room waiting to fuck her. This in turn got me going as she named out several guys who she'd like to fuck including her brother and father. The mere mention of her father blowing some of the seed that made her into her own pussy sent her into an orgasm. 

Soon I was going at her with wreckless abandon but she stopped as she thought she heard a noise downstairs. We stopped the video and held still with only our pounding heartbeats making any sound. We heard clumsy footsteps coming up the stairs and we just froze. Suddenly my girlfriend's 18 year old sister Laura flung open the door to see us still locked in the doggy style position. She was a bit drunk so the sight of her future brother-in-law pussy deep in another girl took a while to set in. Me, I was just mortified. She got in using a key I had given her before when she was at a party when I was away. She didn't want to go home drunk to her parents so she crashed at my place instead. I clean forgot about getting the key back from her and boy was I kicking myself.

I withdrew from Paula who lay back on the bed on top of the covers and went over to Laura to try to explain what she was looking at. My boner was slowly subsiding. As I tried to talk to Laura she kept looking from Paula still naked on the bed to my penis. She wasn't even listening to my babble. Paula remained very calm and winked at Laura every time she looked over. Laura was wearing a pair of tight pants which showed off her small but gorgeous ass very well and a shirt tied up to show off her perfect stomach. Like Paula she had a belly pierced. As she sobered up a wicked grin crept across her face.

She said that she had suspected something between myself and Paula some time ago but said nothing but now she knew for sure. I said "how can I buy your silence?" and again she smiled. Straight up she said "I want some of what she's having", pointing to Paula and then glancing at my now soft cock "and maybe some of that too" redirecting her glance to Paula's pussy. I soon realised that I couldn't say no and the more I thought about the better I felt, so good in fact that my cock started twitching again.

Paula then took over the situation. She got up and started stroking Laura's hair and asking her if we did this would it definitely buy her silence to which Laura nodded yes. Paula continued caressing her face kissing her lightly and opening the knot on the shirt which was tucked up against her small perky tits. Paula kissed close to her lips and then suddenly kissed Laura full on tongues and all. I had only seen this on film so I froze for a moment until Paula beckoned me over while still snogging Laura. I quickly copped on walked over behind Laura and slid the shirt from her slim shoulders and undid her bra ready for Paula to slide off her arms. I then began kissing Laura's neck and she moaned against Paula's luscious lips. Paula then undid Laura's pants and I slid it down her long slender legs to reveal that she was wearing a skimpy thong. That soon hit the floor too.

Paula told me lie back on the bed and led Laura over and told her to start sucking my cock. Laura did as she was told by getting on her hands and knees and lightly kissed along the side of my rod before taking the entire length into her mouth. As Laura was sucking away, Paula moved behind Laura, lay on the bed and positioned herself between Laura's legs and started licking her pussy. I thought, "nice one, one hot chick sucking my cock and another licking that hot chick's pussy". Paula then moved up the crack of Laura's well shaped ass and began licking her asshole, something she rarely did for me. Laura responded by moaning loudly and sucking harder on my cock. Then she licked my balls and down to my own asshole. 

As soon as Paula saw that Laura was now licking my ass, she got out from under Laura and proceeded to replace her at sucking my cock. Paula winked at me as I realised my fantasy had just come through, a hot girl licking my ass and another sucking my cock. Paula was an expert cock sucker and in no time I could feel my nuts boiling and ready to explode. Explode they did and I gushed the biggest fountain of cum I had ever done. Paula simply couldn't contain all of it in her mouth so Laura came to the rescue and lapped up the excess cum around my balls and Paula's face. I lay there gasping for a few minutes before vacating the bed to allow the girls continue their fun.

Paula lay flat on the bed and told Laura to get into the 69 position. The sight of this soon brought my boner back to life again. I watched as the girls lapped each others pussies to orgasm after orgasm. After a while I felt left out so I walked over to Laura who was on top with her perfect little ass in the air and started probing her soaking snatch with my pecker. Paula was licking her clit and lapping up her juices so with one foul swoop I thrust into Laura's tight pussy and couldn't hold back from bucking wildly. Paula divided her attention between Laura's clit and my sack and both of us were thoroughly enjoying the experience. Laura had her face still buried in Paula's snatch and was mewling away nicely.

The thought of banging my future little sister-in-law while my bit-on-the-side was licking us both sent me over the edge again and I blew the third load of the night deep into Laura's chasm. Paula licked up any drips and the three of us relaxed on the bed again for a while.

After a while we drifted off to sleep naked on the bed. In the morning I had my usual morning glory and Laura was quick to get to work sucking it. The noise woke Paula up who said she was left out of the action so I mounted Paula doggie stlye and she licked Laura's pussy who was lain out spread eagled in front of her. My intense bucking soon brought me to another orgasm and Laura had a few at the hands (or should I say face) of Paula. As I was still drained from the night before, I proceeded to taste what little cum I blew from Paula's pussy and licked her to a few more orgasms. I finished off by having both girls kneel on the edge of the bed beside each other and I admired the two most perfect asses in front of me. I probed and licked each pussy with my tongue to get the girls gushing again. The girls kissed while I did this.

We never repeated that night or even came close. I broke up with Laura's sister and banged both Paula and her occasionally but never together. When I meet either of them out, we exchange knowing glances about what happened but a repeat performance is unlikely. I've seen Paula in clubs with her father, perhaps she got her fantasy to come true. Watch that space!